The Magdalene Laundries

Yet another relic of Ireland’s dark and disturbing past has come to light. We are haunted by yet another example of abuse and exploitation by the Catholic Church that went unchallenged for decades. This is the Magdalene Laundries, centres of shame run by nuns from the foundation of the State in 1922 until 1996. A new report has been released detailing the plight of the inmates. Here women were detained and forced to work inhumane hours for no pay. The stigma of being in a Magdalene Laundry was so great that most never spoke if it and left the country. More than 10,000 women were forced to work in essentially labour camps that many have described as slave labour. It is an injustice that forces us all to hang our heads in shame.

The Magdalene Laundries were originally set up in the 1800s to cater for “fallen women”, originally prostitutes but later expanded into unmarried mothers. However, over time this distinction was lost and the report makes it clear that most women were not unmarried or prostitutes. The stigma that they were is one reason why so many have hidden and kept a secret that they were ever inmates. Most women were sent there by the courts (usually for petty theft), social services, foster homes, if they had mental difficulties or were homeless. Sometimes families would send their daughters if they didn’t accept the morals of the time and were too promiscuous (considering the morals of the time anyone less than a puritan could fit this description). Not all women would have been told why they were sent there or how long they had to stay. One of the greatest problems is that for half the women no reason is given as to why they were referred. It was random punishment.

The report finds that the women were placed in a “harsh and physically demanding work environment”. The laundries were “lonely and frightening” places for many of the women. Most women described the atmosphere as “cold” with a “rigid and uncompromising regime of physically demanding work and prayer” with many instances of “verbal censure”. Most women spoke of hurt due to the “loss of freedom”, the “lack of information on when they could leave” and denial of contact with family. One of the greatest cruelties was the removal of every woman’s name upon arrival in the laundry and replacement with a new name by the nuns. To add further humilation and loss of identity, their hair was cut short. They were forbidden from speaking at work, if they were caught they would be hit.  They were mocked and insulted by the nuns, even publicly humiliated. Women who had been abused were sometimes blamed and sent to the laundries. It was used as a dumping ground for problems Catholic Ireland liked to pretend didn’t exist.

There were 10 laundries run by religious orders that catered for 10,000 women over their history. It is a great irony that these cruel and repressive nuns had names such as the Sisters of Charity or Sisters of Mercy. Neither charity nor mercy were shown. For decades the State denied involvement, claiming the laundries were privately operated. However, one quarter of all referrals came from State agencies. State institutions like the Army sent their laundry to be done by the Magdalene.

The Taoiseach Enda Kenny has offered a half apology, stopping short of a full state apology. This has drawn huge criticism from survivors  Maureen Sullivan of Magdalene Survivors Together criticised Kenny saying “That is not a proper apology.” They are looking for a full state apology, back wages and pensions for the few surviving women.

A personal story is given by Permaul who upon entry had her name taken and replaced with Geraldine. She says the feelings of fear entrapment and “that all hope was lost” never go away. Her hair was cut and she was dressed in rags. Survivors describe the laundries as a prison in all but name. They were not given pay, an education or allowed leave. Survivors speak of feeling abandoned and that no one cared. They still live with the stigma and shame. Many still keep their time as a secret. Most women were very young on entry, the youngest being aged 9. The median age was 20. The terms were relatively short, with half being there for less than a year and only a quarter spending longer than 3 years there. The nuns who ran the laundries receive 20 million a year from the state as they still run some hospitals and schools in the country. This is in contrast to survivors who receive nothing.

The Magdalene Laundries are another example of abusive Church power and how conservative Ireland betrayed the most vulnerable. It is symbolic of the harsh and narrow minded attitudes the Church had and why people no longer respect it. These women were powerless and voiceless and Ireland ignored them. They are part of the shameful legacy of the Church and part of the hidden secrets of the past. Let us remember the cruelties they suffered and ensure the survivors get what they deserve.


Filed under Religion

20 responses to “The Magdalene Laundries

  1. This is such a heartbreaking story! The “Church” has done some incredibly hurtful things in the past (and present!), and on behalf of my fellow Christians I must apologize for the things these people did in Ireland. I hope that you (and the world) will at one point or another learn that not all Christians are like these nuns, nor are all of us so legalistic, inhumane, restrictive, and close-minded, and that the message of the Bible and the Christian life is to love one’s neighbor, which includes the prostitutes and those outside of the “faith”.
    These women WERE abusive and shameful, and I believe that their story should be told to warn people of all beliefs that abusing or subjecting people to physical/spiritual/emotional torment for ANY reason has devastating consequences.
    That is why I “liked” this post. It is not because I am a Church-hater, or because I am an atheist, but because any form of human suffering (especially in the name of Christianity/Islam/Judaism/Atheism) breaks my heart.

    • Sorry your comment got caught in the spam folder so I missed it. Thank you for your apology (you’re one of the first to do so, we are still waiting for the Church to do so). I don’t blame Christians for these and other abuses, but I do blame the Irish Catholic Church. It presided and covered up these abuses. At the time the Church was worshiped so much that none dared question it.

      However, had any other religion had the same dominance of society the results would have been similar (though they would have been hard pressed to match Catholics emphasis on guilt and sexual repression). The problem is refusal to question authority and blind acceptance of what you’re told, a problem all religions suffer from. All religions have an authoritarian strand and a preference towards the powerful over the weak.

      I would still be an Atheist regardless of the abuses and they are not a condemnation of Christianity but a warning of when religion grows too powerful.

  2. History abounds with accounts of evil performed in the name of “god”.

    Any “belief system” that enables those in charge to exercise totalitarian control over their “followers” is simply pathological, a pathocracy.

    The hypocrisy of theism is nothing short of breathtaking.

  3. This was more than cruel to those women! I can’t even begin to imagine how wounded the survivors must feel..

  4. Pingback: Response to Robert Neilsen | The O.C. Chronicles

  5. Robert,
    I just posted a long response to the questions to left on my post about prayer. I invite you to read it and extend your thoughts🙂
    here is the link:

  6. I was about to make a joke about soul laundering or something, but I can’t do it. It’s too sick.

  7. Just went you think everything has all been uncovered, more and more comes to light. 😦

  8. One of Canada’s greatest shames is the residential school program. Designed to remove the “Indian” from aboriginal peoples, children were taken from their families and placed in church run schools. Though not limited to Catholics, the Anglican and United churches are at least admitting their faults and trying to address the atrocities that defined this misguided venture. The Catholic church refuses to go on record. For decades these church run schools sexually and physically abused their child labour force.

    • I had never heard of that before. I knew Australia had a similar policy (I saw Rabbit Proof Fence). The Church’s compliance in the eradication of indigenous people and their culture is a serious issue that they never addressed.

  9. Writer, Terry Pratchett describes a similar institution in his book, Monstrous Regiment.
    If you haven’t read it, Robert, I recommend it, especially after reading your post

    • I’ve never read Pratchett but I’ve heard a lot of good things about him, so I really should check him out.

      • He writes comic fantasy, but Monstrous Regiment has a very wicked anti religious theme running through it.
        Hilarious in the main but conscience pricking all the time. I wont say further than that…
        I reckon it’ll be right up your street.🙂

  10. It is long past time we separated Church and State in Ireland. We don’t want to hear about these abuses in the future.

  11. Pingback: The Magdalene sisters | Random thoughts

  12. Pingback: No Defence | Robert Nielsen

  13. Pingback: Adoption and Atheism | fojap

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s